Last modified: 2014-03-09 18:01:42 UTC
We activate the article feedback with bug 29983, we now want to upgrade to version 5, as the consensus of the community: https://pt.wikibooks.org/wiki/T%C3%B3pico:Wikilivros:Di%C3%A1logos_comunit%C3%A1rios/Ativar_Article_feedback_Version_5
Btw, Namespaces: Main, Project, and Help. And we do not intend to transfer the current data. If that delay the installation.
Per bug 43892 and Gerrit change #70349, v4 is now removed from all wikis. So, the only thing left is to install the other extension.
Change 71524 had a related patch set uploaded by Helder.wiki: Install ArticleFeedbackv5 on pt.wikibooks.org https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/71524
And: $wgArticleFeedbackv5LearnToEdit = "//pt.wikibooks.org/wiki/Help:Conteúdos";
Hi folks, we would be happy to help enable AFT5 on pt.wikibooks.org, if it is the wish of the community and is technically feasible. Matthias, what would it take to do that, from your standpoint?
See the consensus of the community here: https://pt.wikibooks.org/wiki/T%C3%B3pico:Wikilivros:Di%C3%A1logos_comunit%C3%A1rios/Ativar_Article_feedback_Version_5
The consensus is above. Please, I need a clear explanation of why it was not activated. Even with the consensus of the community. We are aware that this will increase the work, we are a small community and we want it.
There is a discussion in bug 61163 on whether small wikis should be allowed to use or test ArticleFeedback; your views are welcome.
Hello, I see this bug now for the first time (thanks Tgr). (In reply to Raylton P. Sousa from comment #7) > The consensus is above. Please, I need a clear explanation of why it was not > activated. Even with the consensus of the community. That's a good question, especially as this seems to be the one and only bugzilla report asking AFTv5 with relevant local consensus. The reason is probably that AFTv5 "quotations" were at their all-time low in spring 2013 due to en.wiki affairs (<https://en.wikipedia.org/?oldid=542122121>), you would perhaps have had better luck in 2012-2013 winter. Yes, I know this is not a good reason at all, don't shoot the messenger; I hope that in the future all WMF-developed extensions will first (in early phases of development) be put in use in (several) languages other than English and sister projects, where they are more likely to find committed communities and grow healthy without being ambushed... but I'm afraid this is clearly a "missed train" as we say in Italian (and probably Portuguese too?). If you'd like to reuse something semi-ready and quickly enableable on your wiki by yourself, in my personal capacity as nobody I recommend looking into the pl.wiki tool which you can see by clicking "Report a problem" in English http://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random?uselang=en or "Zgłoś błąd" in Polish (ending up on [[pl:Wikipedia:Zgłoś błąd w artykule]]; see also <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Village_pump/Proposals/Archive/2013/03#Report_a_file_.28feedback.29_tool>).
Change 71524 abandoned by Helder.wiki: Install ArticleFeedbackv5 on pt.wikibooks.org Reason: Change-Id: Ief22aa5fa6ec19dbe368f79392c74a507945e02a Bug: 61163 https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/71524
(In reply to Gerrit Notification Bot from comment #10) > Change 71524 abandoned by Helder.wiki: > Install ArticleFeedbackv5 on pt.wikibooks.org > > Reason: > Change-Id: Ief22aa5fa6ec19dbe368f79392c74a507945e02a > Bug: 61163 > > https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/71524 Closing...
