Last modified: 2012-11-18 10:00:56 UTC
Created attachment 11315 [details] Screenshot * Text overflow is an absolute mess. * Can't open threads anymore (link points to the wrong page, it points to the host page). * No way to open a stand-alone page anymore (the old "My new messages" link to the special page is gone, and there way I can discover to point to a linkable list and/or a no-js fallback) * No way to mark individual notifications as read. When I clicked the link, it opened this overlay and a second later the *10* badge was gone. Previously I could go through individual messages. * ....
(In reply to comment #0) >* No way to open a stand-alone page anymore (the old "My new messages" link to > the special page is gone, and there way I can discover to point to a linkable > list and/or a no-js fallback) > So apparently there is an "All notifications.." link somewhere in the overflow mess. Though that Special page is as broken as the overlay + : * It renders titles inconsistently. Sometimes the title is a link to the host page, sometimes the title is unlinked and the name of the host page becomes a link (see attachment, the bottom one has a title with no link and the hostpage is linked, the top 2 are the other way around).
Created attachment 11316 [details] Screenshot
* Special:Watchlist still says "✒ There are new messages for you." pointing to Special:NewMessages, which is apparently kept out of the loop.
Created attachment 11317 [details] Screenshot This can't be a replacement yet.
> Created attachment 11315 [details] > Screenshot > > * Text overflow is an absolute mess. This is bug 41814 (In reply to comment #0) > * No way to open a stand-alone page anymore (the old "My new messages" link to > the special page is gone, and there way I can discover to point to a linkable > list and/or a no-js fallback) Special:NewMessages, this is bug 41808
We're turning Echo off on MediaWiki.org for now. It's just too early for it to be on a production site. There are also issues with it interfering with existing email notifications.
This bug is not actionable because: * It has unhelpful language like "broken" and "less capable" and "absolute mess". * It addresses a large number of issues, which should be filed as separate bugs. I am opening new bugs for the actionable items.
(In reply to comment #0) > * Text overflow is an absolute mess. Filed as bug 41968. > > * Can't open threads anymore (link points to the wrong page, it points to the > host page). > > * No way to open a stand-alone page anymore (the old "My new messages" link to > the special page is gone, and there way I can discover to point to a linkable > list and/or a no-js fallback) > > * No way to mark individual notifications as read. When I clicked the link, it > opened this overlay and a second later the *10* badge was gone. Previously I > could go through individual messages. I couldn't find those (the last point is not addressed by bug 41808 because that was WONTFIX'ed). (In reply to comment #3) > * Special:Watchlist still says "✒ There are new messages for you." pointing to > Special:NewMessages, which is apparently kept out of the loop. Now bug 41972.
