Last modified: 2013-07-27 05:42:06 UTC
Submitting the form on Enter in the current UI goes against all expectations. It is hardcoded in the javascript to override the default behavior (browsers are actually quite sane in this case and know not to auto-submit from a textarea because that's bad). Either make it not a text area or make it not submit on Enter.
Actually, this is exactly the current behaviour of the edit summary box; see bug 38042 and bug 38735 (the last one submitted by you :-)).
(In reply to comment #1) > Actually, this is exactly the current behaviour of the edit summary box; see > bug 38042 and bug 38735 (the last one submitted by you :-)). Interesting. Was it a textarea back then?
No, previously it was a text input. Patched in https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/23422
Do we really need a textarea? Newlines are not shown in page history.
(In reply to comment #4) > Do we really need a textarea? > > Newlines are not shown in page history. Maybe, maybe not. Either way, that's a separate request. Besides, when it is a text input Enter will submit the form automatically (browser behavior) which is good. So this change had to be made either way. If you want, file a separate ticket to turn it into a single-line text input. Note that textarea provides another thing besides multi-line: wrapping. It is much nicer to type a long line in a textarea then a flat input because there is no need to use the horrible scrubbing behavior that browsers have (select-dragging or keyboard arrows only). I've encountered numerous times during usability studies that a user thought the begin of the input was lost when it was no longer visible (there is no visual indication that it is still there, e.g. scroll or whatever). Or that the end was lost (when they focus another element, other elements scroll back to the begin).
(In reply to comment #5) > Maybe, maybe not. Either way, that's a separate request. > [...] > If you want, file a separate ticket to turn it into a single-line text input. bug 52133
