Last modified: 2006-07-04 08:54:54 UTC
This bug is about the *great feature* of being able to compare two *arbitrary*
oldid's / pages available in the database. It can be used for maintenance.
This *feature* should not be disabeled.
This request is about showing the correct / *actual* titles of *both*
*arbitrary* oldid's / pages.
Originaly one person was generating a link as
but later [[foo]] was moved to [[bar]].
should show the *correct* title *bar* and *not* the *old* title *foo.
If title= is missing [[MediaWiki:Mainpage]] is shown as seccond title. This is
regards reinhardt [[user:gangleri]]
please disregard (In reply to comment #0)
subject changed to
restructure the code to evaluate ?title=foo&oldid=nnnn ; allow ?oldid=nnnn
The scenario is the following:
time period 1) A page A is created
A is modified n times
time period 2) A is moved to B
B is modified n2 times
time period 3) B is moved to C
A is deleted
C is modified n3 times
(optionaly) some revisions are deleted
Now consider the general case of a reference to revisions of this page.
assume that A is [[wiktionary:en:doomsdays]]
B is [[wiktionary:en:Abba]]
C is [[wiktionary:en:abba]]
here title=C all works fine
here title=B still all works fine (only because "Abba" redirects to "abba"!)
here title=A no content is displayed;
please see what links are generated for "view current revision",
"← Older revision" and "Newer revision →"
in addition please see also a "wrong" title (somebody mistyped it)
verify the generated links
what works is also a reference *without* title
*today* the *last* revision is 672681
generate the same page
- oldid=nnnn could be deleted
- oldid=nnnn is out of range
oldid=nnnn is used to refer to a version of a page ; at WP also for citation.
This is why the link should remain "valid" as long as the revision exists in the
database else as long as a such a title exists. I assume that such links would
be hanging around as bookmarks here and there. The task is to offer somthing
usefull to the visitors if the version is still available
Referencing to a version with "oldid" should not be influenced "that much" if
the title does not exist (any more), if the title was deleted (maybe if the
title is invalid etc.) as long as this version exists.
MediaWiki messages can notify that the requested title and the actual titles differ.
I do not know what is best to do if the version does not exist but the title
exists. Should the history be displayed? Other proposals: ... ?
This enhancement request goes hand in hand with
bug 2455: correct navigation links for diffs between two different pages
best regards reinhardt [[user:gangleri]]
When an oldid is provided, the title argument is more or less ignored. So
title=Blah&oldid=1 would work, for instance.