Last modified: 2009-10-30 03:18:12 UTC
1/ Messages rev-deleted-text-unhide, rev-deleted-unhide-diff, and rev-suppressed-text-unhide, have a parameter $1 for the link to the item. Message rev-deleted-text-view is missing a $1 parameter. 2/ There are rev-suppress versions of rev-deleted-text-unhide and rev-deleted-text-view, but there isn't a rev-suppress version of rev-deleted-unhide-diff.
Why would rev-deleted-text-view need one?
The message for rev-deleted-text-view states: This page revision has been '''deleted'''. As an administrator you can view it; there may be details in the [{{fullurl:{{#Special:Log}}/delete|page= {{FULLPAGENAMEE}}}} deletion log]. A message that says "you can view this deleted revision" would probably benefit from being able to link to that view; "where do I click" is going to be an obvious question for this message. (And rev-suppressed-text-view is similar)
Compare: rev-deleted-text-unhide: This page revision has been '''deleted'''... As an administrator you can still [$1 view this revision] if you wish to proceed. rev-deleted-unhide-diff: One of the revisions of this diff has been '''deleted'''... As an administrator you can still [$1 view this diff] if you wish to proceed. rev-deleted-text-view: This page revision has been '''deleted'''... As an administrator you can view it.
I know what they say :) What would the use be?
New diff message in r57172
Click-through. Administrators and oversighters being told it exists and they can see it, would benefit if the message was directly linked to the thing referenced. It's helpful on other messages. Is there a reason that it wouldn't be helpful here?
What do you mean "directly linked to the thing referenced"? Those links are there for the unhide=1 links. Once you click the link, and then can view the content, the message that shows no longer has them since it would just be a URL to the page the user is already on.
Partly, it's not clear where a given message is used. If this is the message for when a user has already clicked through, and is presently viewing the item, then that would explain it. On a similar vein, a few interface message matters have come up in the course of using RevDelete this year, as maybe being worth a change to the extension's default messages. Not many, but a few. Shall I add them to the thread here?
(In reply to comment #8) > Partly, it's not clear where a given message is used. If this is the message > for when a user has already clicked through, and is presently viewing the item, > then that would explain it. > > On a similar vein, a few interface message matters have come up in the course > of using RevDelete this year, as maybe being worth a change to the extension's > default messages. Not many, but a few. Shall I add them to the thread here? > Seems unrelated, so one separate bug that covers them all will do.
