Last modified: 2008-06-13 14:29:43 UTC
Normal editors being logged into Mediawiki by default see the stable version (selecting e.g. 'Article'). I consider this a hugh usability bug as the task of editors is to actually review and edit articles, in contrast to the majority of anonymous users, that are manly interested in read access.
Receiving flagged revision rights today I realised that the new button (between 'Article' and 'Discussion') vanishes, as now by default the newest version is shown. This is the old behaviour and should be given back to normal users. Especially considering that the majority of Wikipedians active for a long time still don't have the special rights:
1) long standing Wikipedians see an old history (more than just annoying),
2) new members waiting for the flag to revise articles also see an old version, though they log in to edit.
Long story short: restore the old view on articles, while keeping the feature for anonymous users. Getting used to the new tab is not an option. Thanks.
What version of FlaggedRevs is this? The default is for anyone logged in to see the current revision.
@Christoph Burgmer: Did you change your preferences at [[de:Spezial:Einstellungen#prefsection-10]]?
(In reply to comment #2)
> @Christoph Burgmer: Did you change your preferences at
Sorry, didn't mention that.
I did: "Benutze für markierte Versionen die einfache Benutzerschnittstelle" is active, I remember to have tried all of them.
I'm speaking of choosing the tabs manually.
I can't reproduce this. Seems to just be a custom preference setting.
Hmm. I don't understand that screenshot. But maybe it is related what occured to me yesterday:
Sometimes (even for logged in users) a "draft" tab and a FlaggedRevs box telling that there is a newer, unsighted revision is shown due to a cache effect. The selected tab is the one showing "article" (stable=1; #ca-stable) then. First thought this would be because of a template change, but then the #ca-current (draft) tab would have had to be active for me. Article itself was changed days ago. Weird.
Ok, for others reading this bug:
The tab "Entwurf" (i.e. non-stable) is superfluous for people with flag-rights, and even for normal signed-on editors.
Please note that I now have flag-rights so I can't check the behaviour for new users. I don't know weather the code treats these two user groups differently, I believe it shouldn't. That's the reason I created this bug.
I altered another actually already audited article just recently and it was then shown with &stable=0 appended to the URL including the superfluous tab.
I'm still seeing the draft be default. I created a new account on .de and it is still the same expected behavior. New and old users are not treated any different, and are not supposed to be as it is set up.
Unneeded tab issues should be started in a new bug.