Last modified: 2012-05-03 02:45:54 UTC
On pl.wikipedia many editors use Special:NewPages to review new pages. After update to MW 1.19 the special page no longer marks unreviewed new pages. It either shows all as not patrolled to sysops, or as reviewed to normal users.
Does https://pl.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Specjalna:Nowe_strony&hideReviewed=1 still hide reviewed pages?
Yes, but the unreviewed pages are no longer marked by background color.
Also changing filter (for example: namespace) and clicking go, and then clicking on "Hide reviewed edits" removes the filter.
To clarify - Polish Wikipedia has FlaggedRevs extensions and the problem are pages marked as 'sighted' which are still on yellow backgound.
(In reply to comment #3)
> To clarify - Polish Wikipedia has FlaggedRevs extensions and the problem are
> pages marked as 'sighted' which are still on yellow backgound.
I tested this on my test wiki and I don't have the problem where pages still show up in yellow even after page review.
I tested plwiki as an 'editor' and a regular user and there was no yellow at all. As a 'sysop', the yellow backgrounds display as expected (yellow <=> reviewed).
The problem is that unreviewed pages are not marked for 'editors'. To sysop they are all shown as yellow, because sysops have '''patrol''' right and Special:NewPages shows that status. We do not use patrol feature built in MediaWiki on pl.wikipedia. Before upgrade it worked just fine and the page shown review status (from FlaggedRevs, not from patrol feature).
It sounds like 'editors' on plwiki should have the 'patrolmarks' right then.
The issue is that sysops see pages marked as yellow which have either reviewed or unreviewed status (from FlaggedRevs extension perspective). That yellow marking is taken from patrol mechanism, not FlaggedRevs which is the issue here.
Created attachment 10125 [details]
I have attached a sample screenshot. It contains pages:
* "Yoo Byung-ok" - page was reviewed, marked as yellow
* "Joanna Sarapata" - page does not have any reviewed versions, marked as yellow
* "Odznaka za zasługi w pracy penitencjarnej" - page was revied, not marked
(In reply to comment #7)
> The issue is that sysops see pages marked as yellow which have either reviewed
> or unreviewed status (from FlaggedRevs extension perspective). That yellow
> marking is taken from patrol mechanism, not FlaggedRevs which is the issue
This is a completely different matter than comment #5. Two different things are being described here:
1) Who can yellow marks on NewPages
2) Whether those yellow marks are correct or not
2) should be fixed in r112653.
1) Done just now.