Last modified: 2008-07-29 21:07:01 UTC
Yesterday I tried to create a thumbnail and resized version of
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Image:Edits_by_contributors_age_en.png - This
didn't work. The image is not shown. I ignored it.
Today a user told me, that there are PNG thumbnails at the wikinews mainpage,
which don't show up.
Examples from this user:
I re-tested my experience from yesterday - still doesn't work:
*** Bug 6317 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
It seems to just happen at a width greater than 99px, I've added an example to
Tim Bartel's test-page for that. I tried to create a thumb of a different image
with thumb.php (as far as I understand the comments in thumb.php it uses the
same engine to create thumbs) which worked with widths >99px.
The first image is the original PNG, it doesn't show properly.
The 2nd image is identical, in GIF format, and behaves perfectly.
another test page:
@PS That aren't the same images. One with a description of the colors which the
other doesn't have.
The problem is that a height of -1 is being returned to the browser.
It seems to have been patched in the development trunk, but
can be superficially fixed by specifying both a width and a height
for the thumb
I've found lots of png's with the error: "Error creating thumbnail: Invalid
For example: [[commons:Image:Wikipe-tan Birthday.png]] and older versions of
[[Image:Map showing NWFP and FATA.png]] (the ones sized 6325×7085)
Browser can display these images without a problem for the non-resized version
A similar problem is occurring with jpegs as well - instead of the image, the caption is returned as a link to the image. Examples shown here, flagged with that little warning icon thingie.
Main problem, at least with this image, is that it occurs at the default size. I've seen it occur elsewhere, but I just noticed today that someone else is having a similar problem.
It's been one year since the last comment here, and I haven't heard widespread complaints about continuing problems. I'm closing WORKSFORME, reopen if it's still an issue.