Last modified: 2014-04-15 06:22:16 UTC
Created attachment 7508 [details] Talk page bottom with same category shown three times I've inserted a category in the talk header, in a thread summary and in a single message: it works (the single thread isn't summarized actually and it looks so, but this isn't a big issue), but the category is shown three times. This bug would be really annoying in the case of subpaged threads (e.g. subpaged village pumps with a page for each day with multiple threads in it, where every day and every thread is categorized, as e.g. in it.wiki or it.news, and where we will hopefully have transcluded threads, see http://liquidthreads.labs.wikimedia.org/wiki/Thread:Feedback/No_way_to_multi-home_a_thread%3F#No_way_to_multi-home_a_thread.3F_855 ). Example: see URL and attachment.
While this behavior is annoying right now, this is a design issue (e.g., how do we *want* it to behave?) so I am taking it.
Created attachment 8713 [details] Non-existent category shown three times Another crazy example, from <http://translatewiki.net/wiki/Thread:Support/Internal_error_(2)> (which now doesn't show anything). The category was actually on <http://translatewiki.net/wiki/Thread:Support/About_MediaWiki:Smw_qc_query_help/en/reply_(6)>
(In reply to comment #0) > http://liquidthreads.labs.wikimedia.org/wiki/Thread:Feedback/No_way_to_multi- > home_a_thread%3F#No_way_to_multi-home_a_thread.3F_855 This thread is also saved as attachment 11078 [details].
Description of the current behavior. A category added to a thread shows in two places: * At the bottom of the Talk page along with all other categories on that Talk page's threads. * On the individual thread's summary page. Each time the category tag is added to a reply or a thread, it is repeated at the bottom of both views. The problem here appears to be that Categories on both views should be de-duped before display.